No wide receiver ever had a greater year in the NFL than Randy Moss did in
2007. He set a record with 23 touchdown catches in working with Tom Brady to
spearhead what looked to be the best NFL team that ever took the field ... well,
until the Super Bowl.
The sleek 6-foot-4, 210-pounder also led the league in TD catches ...
obviously the most important stat for a receiver, and many of them were
spectacular leaping grabs ... in 1998, 2000 and 2003, establishing himself as
the NFL's most powerful big-play threat ... when he felt like it, anyway.
But Moss isn't the greatest NFL wide receiver of all time. I rank him second.
Jerry Rice is still the best ... not only for individual brilliance but
long-time consistency. He is the career leader in TD catches (197), receptions
(1,549) and yardage (22,895) ... those are just a few among the many he holds
... as great as Moss is, no player has dominated his position like Rice.
The rest of my top 10:
3 -- Terrell Owens. Forget (if you can) his antics off the field ... on the
field, he's a master. He's third on the all-time TD reception list with 129 and
with his next two this season, he will vault into second place behind Rice.
Owens holds the NFL record for most receptions in a game (20 for San Francisco
vs. Chicago in 2000). Defenses have to account for him on every play.
4 -- Marvin Harrison. Chicken or the egg ... did Peyton Manning make him
great or did he help Manning look great? We'd say both. Until injured in 2007,
he enjoyed 11 seasons in a row of 50 or more catches (tied for third all-time)
and he holds the NFL record for most receptions in a season (143 in 2002).
5 -- Michael Irvin. A big part of the Cowboys' dynasty of the 1990s, Irvin
was known both for his ability to make tough catches down the middle and to
break long gainers. He caught 75 or more passes five seasons in a row.
6 -- Paul Warfield. You won't find Warfield high on the all-time receiving
lists ... he was quality, not quantity, as a human guided missile in the 1960s
for the Browns and Dolphins. He averaged an astounding 20.1 yards per reception
over his career and of his 427 catches, 85 went for TDs.
7 -- Raymond Berry. He's the epitome of a player who used clever moves and
grit to atone for a lack of speed. Not even a starter until his third year with
the (Baltimore) Colts, he proceeded to lead the NFL in receptions three years in
a row. In the fabled 23-17 overtime victory over the Giants for the 1958 title,
the game said to have put the NFL on the map, he snagged 12 passes for 194 yards
and a TD. He needed special shoes because one leg was shorter than the
other.
8 -- Don Hutson. The first great pro receiver back in the 1930s and '40s for
Green Bay, he amazingly still holds records for most years leading the NFL in
receptions (eight), reception yards (seven) and reception touchdowns (nine). In
fact, he caught an 83-yard TD strike on his first play in the NFL ... although
all of this, of course, was against lesser competition than today. Could he play
now? Since he was a 9.8 sprinter and a master of fakes and changing speeds, why
not?
9 -- Tim Brown. The Raiders' career leader in games played, he ranks second
all-time in the NFL in yards gained (14,934) and third in receptions (1,094) .
He also led the league in kickoff returning and punt returning in separate
seasons.
10 -- Bob Hayes. Of all the trackmen who have tried football, Hayes is
undoubtedly the most successful. He used his 9.1 speed in the 100 for the
Cowboys to haul in 71 TD catches, returned punts for another three and forced
defenses into zone coverage.
Among today's young wideouts, a pair of Johnsons ... Andre of the Texans and
Calvin of the Lions ... could join this list someday if they could only get a
big-time QB to throw to them. Cleveland's Braylon Edwards has the potential,
too. Cris Carter (second all-time to Rice with 1,101 receptions), Isaac Bruce
(third all-time in yards gained, and he could add more this year), Lance Alworth
(holds record for most 200-yard receiving games with five), Harold Carmichael
(at 6-8, hard to miss), Lynn Swann (go-to guy for the Steelers' powerhouses of
the '70s) and Otis Taylor (at 6-3, 215 but with 4.5 speed, one of the first big
guys to play WR) rank as our honorable mentions.